International Shortcomings in the Overseas Nurse Recruitment Plan

International Shortcomings in the Overseas Nurse Recruitment Plan

The Struggling Success Program:

The Ministry of Immigration's ambitious plan to recruit foreign nurses has seen a striking surge in failure rates. The first cohort, followed by the second and third, recorded a concerning trend - 7%, 9%, and 11% of international nurses either dropped out or failed. As for the most recent batches from Francophone Africa, dropout numbers are climbing, according to our investigations.

Even the retake groups are providing cause for concern amongst program managers. At CEGEP Édouard-Montpetit, 50% of second chance students are flunking the final module of their supplementary training. The latest cohort, which completed on April 11, resulted in 6 out of 13 students failing. Such high failure rates have reportedly prompted the Ministry of Immigration, Francization, and Integration (MIFI) to demand an explanation from CEGEP Édouard-Montpetit regarding the support provided to students.

Claudine Ellyson, Director of Continuing Education at CEGEP Édouard-Montpetit, acknowledges the failure rate as a setback but stresses the importance of meeting the program's objectives. "While it's painful to see students struggle, our mandate is fulfilled when the competencies and profession requirements are met," Ellyson explains. She emphasizes that this particular retake cohort consisted of students with additional challenges.

Lost Faith

Our investigations spoke with several retake cohort students at CEGEP Édouard-Montpetit, who remain anonymous to protect their careers. Sophie, one such student, shares her frustration: "I no longer want to continue the program. It's too grueling." She feels the teachers see them as inadequate and refers to the atmosphere as "very cold and tense."

These African nurses report an air of subjectivity in their evaluations, with vague criteria and a feeling that passing depended on the teacher's mood. Students claim they were graded too harshly and criticize the teaching methods as inadequate. According to reports, one student was even failed for performing a medical gesture in the absence of their teacher.

"I no longer want to continue the program. It's too grueling."

- Sophie

Several students have also caused concern due to their forgetfulness, such as forgetting to record information in a patient's file.

Lack of Support

MIFI claims it is not accountable for academic success but is quick to respond when failure risks arise. Reports indicate that the MIFI mobilized partners only when the cohort resuming at Édouard-Montpetit showed signs of failure.

Sources claim that the MIFI required CEGEP Édouard-Montpetit to meet the Nursing Care Consortium, intended to provide educational support to the participating CEGEPs, only two weeks before the end of the session.

Eric April, director of continuing education at CEGEP Vieux Montréal, admits that help came too late. "Naturally, we are committed to understanding the needs of our CEGEP [Édouard-Montpetit] and expressed our concerns when we learned of the potential failures [which eventually became 6 confirmed failures]."

Claudine Ellyson insists that help was never withheld but suggests her CEGEP is already well-equipped to handle the situation, with offerings such as supervised practice opportunities, peer tutoring, and access to professionals.

While the CEGEP Édouard-Montpetit failure rate still remains a concern, a new chance might be offered to the 6 students who flunked, albeit without additional financial aid from the MIFI, which does not provide funding beyond two failures.

Additional Insights:

• Internationally educated nurses (IENs) often face challenges such as credential recognition, cultural differences, and language barriers when adapting to new healthcare systems.
• The global nursing workforce is currently experiencing a crisis, exacerbating the difficulties faced by IENs as they integrate into new systems.
• Innovative programs, like Hôpital Montfort's, aim to bridge the gap between theoretical knowledge and practical skills for IENs.

1. The struggling international nurses, specifically those from Francophone Africa, are finding the French-language program difficult, leading to climbing dropout numbers.
2. Despite the concerns about the high failure rates, CEGEP Édouard-Montpetit maintains that they have resources available for students, including peer tutoring and supervised practice opportunities.
3. The retake cohort students at CEGEP Édouard-Montpetit feel undermined and dissatisfied with the program, citing a grueling course, harsh grading, and inadequate teaching methods as reasons for their frustration.
4. The science of teaching and learning could benefit from further research to address the needs of internationally educated nurses (IENs) who face language barriers, cultural differences, and credential recognition challenges in health-and-wellness fields like nursing.
5. The weather of disappointment hangs over the education-and-self-development path of many IENs, as they navigate medical-conditions and science-related courses with little to no additional financial aid, even after multiple failures.

Read also: